Saturday, May 19, 2007

King's Two Bodies

To my regular readers.. (twif and Keif) -- this is part of a long discussion with Geoff about The King's Two Bodies. If anybody for some reason has the urge to catch up/join in, you can check out his blog Geoff's Musings. Sorry this is so tedious -- its just that working out ideas is often kind of ugly along the way.

What exactly is the problem in The King's Two Bodies? It is partly a question of origins, or at least of precedents: how did the notion of a single person containing "a Body natural, and a Body politic" come about? It is also a question of effects: what were the consequences of the different manifestations of this doctrine and its antecedents?

I think following up Plowden with Shakespeare addresses the second of these questions as well as the first. It's not simply a question of legal doctrine, it's an examination of the interchange between legal doctrine and a wider culture. Lawyers as well as playwrights must wrestle with problems of kingship – it's a question of royal (yet underaged) gift of the Duchy of Lancaster, and also a question of the way the dual king/King is understood, and (through the brilliance of Shakespeare) understands himself.

So far, the implications of the doctrine include law, self-image of the monarch, and the notion of sovereignty. I'm just going to go through a few more that seemed suggestive to me.

Theology

Kantorowicz also sees issues of theology; (p. 17)


…It is of great interest to note how in sixteenth-century England, by the efforts of jurists to define effectively and accurately the King's Two Bodies, all the Christological problems of the early Church concerning the Two Natures once more were actualized and resuscitated in the early absolute monarchy.


I've mentioned a few times now that a classic way of generating political power is by coupling a hierarchical relationship to existing ideas of the cosmos or the body. It's a tricky move, however, for it also means a kind of surrender to the expertise of those thought to know about the cosmos or the body. I'm not sure what level to take Kantorowicz here – is he simply creating his own metaphor, with Aryanism and Nestorianism convenient literary tropes for describing what he wishes to communicate? Or does he think that Trinitarian logic/debate helped figure the depictions of the king?
Here's E.K. (pp. 18-19) :


The implication is not that the lawyers consciously borrowed from the acts of the early Councils, but that the fiction of the King's Two Bodies produced interpretations and definitions which perforce would resemble those produced in view of the Two Natures of the God-man.


He goes on to say that this similarity is "unsurprising." I do wonder, however, whether the English Civil War and its discourse of the King's Two Bodies wasn't closely related to its questioning of the theological edifice on which this duality rested (or at least, which allowed the duality to make sense).

One other note about the Plowden chapter: to what extent is the dual nature of the king really a "fiction"? It isn't clear to me what Kantorowicz means by the terms. He shows that it’s a rather compelling and long lived fiction? I guess it's not clear to me how this concept might be more or less of a fiction than, say, habeas corpus, or private property, or anything else.


Ritual

The bit of the Shakespeare chapter that particularly raised my eyebrows was on pp. 36-37. Richard II is King and king. The King will continue in a new king, but only a King can effect such a separation. So Richard as King must preside over the abdication – and none other has the power to do so.

According to Kantorowicz (p. 36) "Bit by bit he deprives himself of the symbols of his dignity," but some of Shakespeare's lines seem anything but symbolic (unless the medieval term "symbol" carries some reality I do not understand). It's true Richard gives up crown and scepter, but also "The pride of kingly sway from out my heart/with mine own tears I wash away my balm."

I think that Kantorowicz returns to a reading of the burial of a monarch. That must also be a ritually tricky moment, because one is burying king but not King. What else might fall in the same category? It's this kind of situation I was referring to when I spoke of "kinks" earlier in the conversation.

Also on the subject of ritual – why is the Christ-centered king "liturgical"? I understand the division between a model or Christ and a model of Justice -- but I don’t get the division
liturgical/juristical (for example, page 93).

Language

This is such a quick thought it hardly merits a subsection, but I found the argument about "demise" on page 40 (in which the word "convey" is particularly significant) rather compelling.

At any rate, Kantorowicz's "problem strikes me as a far-reaching one indeed. All I really have to add to what you've said about the "Christ-Centered Kingship" is that the valences of the problem remain multiple in each section. Each example is of law, and of much else. That's one reason the word "secular" bugs me (I've mentioned this before). It seems to cut off certain kinds of associations that strike me as significant

Curious what you made of the argument about the persona mixta on pp. 43-44. You spoke of the commonplace of dual personality in law, and this seems to be another example. There are an awful lot (see the "dual majesties" on p. 20 and the functional duality of man and office on p. 59. And of course the dual natures of Christ I mentioned above). We read that "a certain spiritual capacity was attributed to [the king] as an effluence of his consecration and unction" – again, a power of ritual. But this differs, argues E.K., from the King's Two Bodies—except in certain cases like the Norman Anonymous? or is E.K. doubling back on his own argument, and I just haven't followed the rhetoric?

I don't understand what gemina persona means. But I do get the idea of the dual capacities of the Christlike king, and its expression in..

Art
The haloed Byzantine emperors, and the frontispiece of the Aachen gospels.

So those I think are the spheres we are working with (though surely there are others as well. I guess that's what interests me so much about law (and about this book) – the way its language, symbols, structures, etc. bleed into other areas of life. It seems to me this must be a real problem for lawyers (well, maybe just for judges). The injunction to follow the word of the law seems to me kind of impossible, for the law is everywhere, and it doesn't always make sense.

For that matter, I don't either, and if you have it in you to push me to clarify any of that (especially the last part), let me know.

22 comments:

Keifus said...

Um, I'll try to return (Monday, good chance) when I'm not in the middle of being a drunken doofus. See if you can't stop by my place though--you're mentioned just now.

K

topazz said...

what am I, chopped liver here? So, where are the sex stories?

august said...

Sorry topazz. I was remiss in not mentioning the parallel theory of "The King's Two Penises"

Keif -- I'll swing by

twiffer said...

looks interesting. i'm going to have to read it in bits though, and save commentary for the end.

this it the problem with reading you during work hours.

twiffer said...

how much of this idea of duality do you suppose is residual of the king as a god incarnate?

Keifus said...

God I hate the king.

Oh, and from Connecticut Yankee... (right on page 1)
The question of whether there is such a thing as the Divine Right of kings is not settled in this book. It was found too difficult. That the executive head of a nation be a person of lofty character and extraordinary ability, was manifest and indisputable; that the Deity could select that head unerringly was, likewise manifest and indisputable; consequently, that he does make it, as claimed, was an unavoidable deduction. I mean, until the author of this book encountered the Pompadour and the Lady Castlemain, and some other executive heads of that kind...

So, uh, good luck with that.

Anonymous said...

Wanna Get HIGH? Running out of Supply? Then Check Out My Shit!
>>>>> http://bestlegalhighsdrugs.info <<<<
If you have questions, you can email my boy at online.mentor [at] gmail.com


[size=1] IGNORE THIS----------------------------
ecdtasy pills savlia divinorim [url=http://bestlegalhighsdrugs.info] natural highs [/url] Legal Weed Alternative kratom in stores [url=http://buybudshoplegalherbs.info] smoking legal herbs[/url] drug abuse test Estacy [url=HTTP://BUYINGMARIJUANASALE.INFO] Buy Ganja [/url] Estacy peyote [url=HTTP://BUYLEGALBUDSCOMREVIEWS.INFO] buy legalbuds [/url] is salvia divinorum legal psylocybin mushrooms [url=HTTP://CANNABISHIGH-PILLSHIGH.INFO] High Quality Marihuana[/url] amanitaa kuscaria amanuta muscaris [url=HTTP://HOWTOBUYWEED-BUYINGWEED.INFO] buying marijuana[/url] bufi alvarius bbufo slvarius [url=http://legalbud.drugreviews.info] legal buds [/url]

amaanita muscarai pass a drug screen [url=http://legalweed.lamodalatina.com] legal weeds [/url] salvoa divknorum sslvia divinorim [url=http://buysalvia.lamodalatina.com] get salvia extract[/url] magic mushrooms pictures Steroids

2 day detox ssalvia divinroum [url=http://legalweed.lamodalatina.com] legalweed [/url] psilocybe mushrooms & their allies slavia duvinorum [url=http://buysalviacheap.com] buy salvia extracts[/url] salvia shop hashish history
[url=http://guaranteedheightincrease.info/]height improvement[/url] - http://guaranteedheightincrease.info/
height improvement - http://guaranteedheightincrease.info
[url=http://provenpenisenlargement.info/]proven penis growth[/url] - http://provenpenisenlargement.info/
proven penis lengthening - http://provenpenisenlargement.info/
[url=http://provenskincareadvice.info/]skin care advice[/url] - http://provenskincareadvice.info/
skin care techniques - http://provenskincareadvice.info/
[url=http://getrichgambling.info/]get money gambling[/url] - http://getrichgambling.info/
get rich gambling - http://getrichgambling.info/
[url=http://herpesoutbreak-gentalwarts.info/]herpes outbreak[/url] - http://herpesoutbreak-gentalwarts.info/
herpes outbreak - http://herpesoutbreak-gentalwarts.info/
[url=http://STOP-PREMATURE-EJACULATION-SOLUTIONS.INFO]stop premature ejaculation[/url] - http://STOP-PREMATURE-EJACULATION-SOLUTIONS.INFO
stop premature ejaculation - http://STOP-PREMATURE-EJACULATION-SOLUTIONS.INFO
[url=http://3GMOBILEPHONESFORSALE.INFO]mobile cellphones for sale[/url] - http://3GMOBILEPHONESFORSALE.INFO
used mobile cellphones for sale - http://3GMOBILEPHONESFORSALE.INFO
[url=http://internationaloddities.reviewsdiscountsonline.com] international oddities review[/url]
international oddities scam
[url=http://drobuds.reviewsdiscountsonline.com]dro buds review [/url]
review of dro buds
[url=http://bestacnetreatmentreviews.info] best acne treatment reviews[/url] http://bestacnetreatmentreviews.info
best acne treatment review http://bestacnetreatmentreviews.info
[url=HTTP://LEARN-HYPNOSIS-ONLINE.INFO]learn hypnotism online[/url]
learn hypnotism online

Anonymous said...

if you guys desideratum to secure the fancy [url=http://www.generic4you.com]viagra[/url] online you can do it at www.generic4you.com, the most trusted viagra pharmaceutics advantageously of generic drugs.
you can invoke up drugs like [url=http://www.generic4you.com/Sildenafil_Citrate_Viagra-p2.html]viagra[/url], [url=http://www.generic4you.com/Tadalafil-p1.html]cialis[/url], [url=http://www.generic4you.com/VardenafilLevitra-p3.html]levitra[/url] and more at www.rxpillsmd.net, the pre-eminent [url=http://www.rxpillsmd.net]viagra[/url] provenience on the web. well another great [url=http://www.i-buy-viagra.com]viagra[/url] pharmacy you can find at www.i-buy-viagra.com

viagra online said...

this kind of topic is good for people to learn more about it, and that people should be every day less ignorant, and medicine for this is the reading of issues like this

Anonymous said...

Infatuation casinos? certify this progeny [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com]online casinos[/url] navigator and horseplay online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at www.realcazinoz.com .
you can also go over our novel [url=http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com]casino[/url] hint at http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com and take factual genially distant !
another unsurpassed [url=http://www.ttittancasino.com]casino spiele[/url] regard is www.ttittancasino.com , because german gamblers, arrange manumitted online casino bonus.

Anonymous said...

Predilection casinos? probe this advanced [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com]online casino[/url] guide and fake online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at www.realcazinoz.com .
you can also into our up to the minute [url=http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com]casino[/url] shun at http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com and draw realized spondulix !
another modern [url=http://www.ttittancasino.com]casino spiele[/url] position is www.ttittancasino.com , because german gamblers, submit c be communicated via loose online casino bonus.

Anonymous said...

Hello folks,

What online zines do you read and would recommend?

For all you emo folks out there I recommend The Enough Fanzine. It is one of the first rock ezines on the www.

They have throusands of interviews from the most underground bands all over the world. Check them out online: [url=http://www.enoughfanzine.com]Enough Fanzine[/url]. Best of it all, they are 100% non-profit and just helping the scene!

Looking forward to your recommendations.

Regards!

Anonymous said...

Everything about horse betting

We came across an article on ESPN.com written by Bill Finley entitled "2005 was a lousy year for horse racing." In his article Mr. Finley cites 9 reasons why 2005 was such a bad year for horse racing in America. Although we agree with several of his observations, number 8 on his list, "U.S. Pari-Mutuel Handle Falls", should have been dealt with more objectively.
[url=http://www.pulsebet.com]horse betting[/url]
There are however many controversies surrounding the horse industry. During races, some jockeys use a crop to hit the horse in the rump to direct their effort and possibly run faster. Based on the most detailed statistical study of whipping ever carried out, it is actually counterproductive and slows the horse down causing them to become distracted and dangerously go off course.


Will Barbaro be the next Triple Crown winner? He has the breeding and the talent, but as of this writing twenty horses have won the first two legs of the Triple Crown only to fail at Belmont. Twenty five more have won two of the three races, but maybe this year...

[url=http://www.pulsebet.com]bet on horses[/url]
As the field takes shape for the 131st running of the Preakness Stakes this Saturday, the question on everyone's minds is do we finally have a horse that can win the Triple Crown?

Anonymous said...

1.) Some game sites post information about the number of players currently playing at a particular game of bingo. Accordingly, you have to plan the number of bingo cards in your online bingo game. More numbers of cards yield better results when the number of players is low. Your winning percentage is then higher.
[url=http://www.bingokisses.com]new bingo[/url] play bingo One of the winning systems is to play with fewer bingo cards. Most bingo players play with many bingo cards to increase their chances of a win at the game. However, playing with fewer cards provides the best odds of the game as your chances of making a big win are higher. Another bingo system in action functions according to the theory of probability. Balls from a bingo machine come out at random, which means that no one can predict emergence of any particular number. In the same vein, you can employ the probability theory to gauge the next number to emerge from the machine. Random drawing of numbers means laws of probability govern selection of balls and their appearance in a uniform distribution pattern.
[url=http://www.bingokisses.com]bingo online[/url]
Bingo is a fantastic game and is fast becoming one of the most popular forms of entertainment on the internet, our advice is to have fun and be safe, we wish you all the luck in the world with your bingo playing, thanks for reading.
bingo online
In bingo, each player will get a sheet, which has six cards with a total of 90 numbers. On each one of these bingo cards, you will find 27 spaces grouped in 9 columns x 3 rows format. Each number is unduplicated; hence, it will not be repeated anywhere else in the sheet.

Anonymous said...

So I pulled out the old credit card -- bought myself a [url=http://www.ordio.com.au/products/Fatman-iTube-ValveDock-Carbon-Edition-2.html]Fatman iTube Valve Dock Carbon Edition[/url] and I've got to say I am pleasantly surprised. I actually listened to one at a friend's house several months back and just couldn't get that quality out of my head because it impressed the heck out of me. I searched everywhere for a great deal and finally found it at [url=http://www.ordio.com.au]Ordio[/url] in Westfield Bondi Junction. I called them up first and asked every question I could think of and everything was answered to my satisfaction so I went ahead and bought it. Shipping was very fast. Everything was perfect. I'm pretty darn happy and I'm playing it right now. Not sure if they post outside of Australia but you won't be sorry if they do.

Outstanding...

Jim

Anonymous said...

Genial fill someone in on and this mail helped me alot in my college assignement. Thanks you as your information.

Anonymous said...

Как говорилось на [url=http://www.soki.tv]Seexi.net[/url] Да , я прекрасно понимаю , что все это зависит от человека , но у меня нет таких лидерских способностей , пробивных, коие хотя бы не очень большую гарантию дали, что все с работой ок может быть . Я тихая и спокойная и непрезентабельная (и очень ответственности боюсь) ,но все-таки и стремление стать начальницей ))) профи есть ))), . Надеюсь просто , что со временем ко мне уверенность придет и я добьюсь чего хочу . в данный момент с работой не клеится абсолютно . мне 24
спасибо !

Anonymous said...

hello i came here by the site online casino games

discussed short article, sooo want to discover whatever you write about following!
play casino games

Anonymous said...

Just about every PPC aFvertisement shoulF be put together with a qualiFieF lanFing web page. A webmaster ought to not senF reaFers just [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
the homepage as being the homepage can be Far too generic. Utilizing the homepage as lanFing site continues to be conFirmeF [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
get Fecrease conversion rate[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
It is oFten unFerstooF that when something is urgent, numerous small business proprietors are likely [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
accomplish it right away. But when some thing is crucial, numerous small business entrepreneurs help it become a Fegree [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
prioritize it oF their listing oF items [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
be carrieF out. Consequently, what are urgent will oFten be those that are oFFereF aFFitional awareness anF perFormeF immeFiately, although many It is clear you will want [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
have as a lot oF achievable search phrases insiFe oF pertaining http://www.germanylovelv.com/
your specializeF niche current market on the worlF wiFe web web page as a way http://www.germanylovelv.com/
Frive Far more persons [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton kopierte Tasche kaufen[/url]
your website. Whilst you will Fiscover 1000's oF keyworF phrases anF mixtures oF keyworFs, not [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
mention misspellings, that probable shoppers may seek For, you are going to want [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
make convinceF you may have every one oF the most popular lookup terms anF as a lot oF the some others as is possible. These keyworFs anF phrases equal WorlF-wiFe-web web site site visitors, which equals money anF is particularly unquestionably value your time anF energy [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
put Forth the hassle [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton kopierte Tasche kaufen[/url]
FinF out what the preFerreF search phrases are For your personal niche business..
|
These Fays many people are useF [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
a Fisappointing customer experience such as impersonal service, lackluster proFucts anF no eFFort [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
go the extra mile. Smart companies, however, are placing a greater emphasis on proviFing an excellent overall experience For their valueF customer[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
These companies set themselves apart by striving [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
proviFe the highest-quality proFucts anF services..

Anonymous said...

Did you [url=http://www.onlinecasinos.gd]casinos[/url] close to that you can on Enterprise Lobby at contribution from your mobile? We stay a peerlessness unfixed casino elbow against iPhone, iPad, Android, Blackberry, Windows 7 and Smartphone users. Peculate your gaming with you and be a title-holder [url=http://www.appydomain.info]dildo[/url] wherever you go.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://zone.aimoo.com/blog/longchampsoldesk]sacs longchamp[/url] The predecessor relating to the Hibore hybrid could be the Mulberry Tony Laptop Briefcase Black for Men,Buy cheap Mulberry bags from Mulberry uk official factory shop Halo line about golfing gear that are however out there and furthermore still common. As soon as yet again the "inverted Crown" is obvious coupled with fat is redistributed for the perimeter connected with the club, lowering the CG and ever-increasing MOI, as talked about over. It really is claimed the Halo line generates pictures which are five-10 yards extended as opposed to irons they replace..
[url=http://longchampsoldes.blog.com/]sac longchamp moins cher[/url] As I like organization, I did add a purse organizer which fit perfectly and still left plenty of room for all my things. It is really well made and looks great in the Coach. Here is a picture of the organizer. When we think of savings, money easily comes into place. In Style Mulberry Women's Alexa Leather Satchel Red Bag. We sale all kinds of the newsest style that all are cheap price and high quality. Shopping can be addictive, and it correlates spending money. Oftentimes, we really want to save our money whenever we go shopping.
[url=http://sportsrantz.com/longchamppliagea/]sac longchamp[/url] Precisely what packages custom natural leather bags in addition to the usual products are their own highly sought after types, carefully hand-crafted together with hand painted natural leather body shapes, large pouches and elegant look together with standard complete category. Taking some sort of natural leather bag provides user a promising encounter together with can make you feel good! What is even more, you needn't traipse regarding the marketplaces looking for a fitting natural leather bag or simply billfold. By using many online store internet sites, focused upon natural leather products and services, procuring is simple.. Kilbourne's film Killing Us Softly 3: Advertising's Image of Women (2000) looked at the effects of sexual objectification on self-esteem and body images of women. Kilbourne found that women's insecurities about their "imperfect" bodies could 2013 Mulberry Online Shop on Sale Discount Chic supply Mulberry Women's Daria Leather Clutch Gray Bag is affordable be directly traced back to sexual objectification. Advertisements have set the standard for the most desirable women, a body image that only a miniscule percent of the female population can attain..

Anonymous said...

LED flowering grow lights will produce light in the right frequency
and wavelength. For the LED light, there are mainly
3 kinds of white colors - warm white, natural white and cool white.
The much talked about drawback, the lack of evenly distributed light in LED lamps
too has been now satisfactorily sorted out by Sharp with their proprietary coating technique of the
glass enclosure.

Also visit my blog post :: LED Stehleuchten